The 15 Best Restaurants in McCall, ID for 2023 (Top Eats!) (2023)

Welcome to McCall, Idaho - the perfect destination for foodies looking for a unique dining experience.

From exquisite fine dining to rustic local favorites, this small mountain town has a variety of delicious dining options to choose from.

Treat your taste buds by exploring the top McCall restaurants we have listed below.

1. Ice cream shop

310 E Lake St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-1136

Locally owned, Ice Cream Alley has been a summertime staple of homemade ice cream for nearly 40 years.

Why this restaurant is a must

Head to Ice Cream Alley to get away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life.

From the sweet smell of the waffle cones to the cheerful murals on the walls, it's impossible not to feel the warmth and charm of the store.

The ice cream selection is large and varied, offering flavors from around the world.

From classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to unique flavors like blueberry cheesecake and mango sorbet, there's something for everyone.

what to eat

The most popular ice cream is undoubtedly the signature Ice Cream Alley Sundae.

It starts with a freshly baked waffle cone topped with two scoops of your favorite ice cream and finishes with a drizzle of hot fudge and a sprinkling of crushed peanuts.

2. My father's house

901 N 3. St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-4401

My Father's Place is a family run restaurant serving classic American favorites since 1989.

Why this restaurant is a must

My Father's Place is the perfect place to relax and soak up the atmosphere of a cozy mountain town.

The atmosphere is filled with the warmth of a family gathering, with a friendly and welcoming atmosphere.

The walls are adorned with family pictures and the decor is rustic and charming.

The menu is packed with classic American fare with all your favorites, from burgers and fries to steak and seafood.

Whether for breakfast or brunch, this is one of the most popular restaurants.

what to eat

We recommend the signature My Father's Place prime rib.

This juicy cut of prime rib is slow roasted to perfection and served with a creamy horseradish sauce and a side of mashed potatoes.

3. Stacey Cake

136 E Lake St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-2537

Stacey Cakes is a locally owned bakery and restaurant serving sweet and savory pastries, soups and custom cakes in downtown McCall.

Why this restaurant is a must

This next spot is considered one of the best birthday restaurants in McCall.

For the simple reason that their birthday cakes are beyond compare.

The welcoming atmosphere is filled with the sweet aromas of freshly baked goods, and the warm and cozy decor creates a comfortable and inviting place to relax.

With a wide range of cakes, cookies, cupcakes and other delicious treats, there is something for everyone.

what to eat

The bakery's most popular dish is the classic chocolate cake - a rich and delicious cake made with decadent layers of dark chocolate and creamy ganache.

The cake is topped with a delicious drizzle of chocolate icing, giving it a beautiful glossy finish.

Each bite is a heavenly blend of flavor and texture that will leave you wanting more.

Recommended hotels nearby: Third Street Inn

See also:
Boise-Restaurants

4. Steamers

308 E Lake St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-1411

Steamers is a local staple known for serving steaks, seafood and wine in a rustic-chic setting.

Why this restaurant is a must

Steamers is a cozy restaurant in the heart of stunning Payette Lake.

The restaurant has a warm and welcoming atmosphere with its rustic wood paneling and log cabin decor.

The atmosphere is enhanced by the beautiful view of the lake, which you can enjoy from the large windows.

With such breathtaking views, it might as well be called fine dining in McCall.

what to eat

The restaurant serves a variety of delicious dishes, but the most popular dish is the steamer special.

This dish features succulent shrimp, succulent mussels, and tender mussels, all steamed to perfection in a hearty garlic butter sauce.

The flavor of the seafood is complemented by a zesty lemon and white wine sauce, making it a truly mouth-watering experience.

Recommended hotels nearby: Best Western Plus McCall Lodge and Suites

5. Nice town

1007 West Lake St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-2270

Pueblo Lindo is a family-run restaurant that serves authentic Mexican dishes in a casual atmosphere.

Why this restaurant is a must

The Pueblo Lindo is full of vibrant colors and rustic decor that creates a cozy atmosphere.

The walls are adorned with colorful Mexican artwork, giving the space a lively, lively feel.

No visit to Pueblo Lindo is complete without trying the tacos.

It's hands down one of McCall's best places for dinner if you're looking for casual places to eat with a fellow food lover.

what to eat

The restaurant's most popular dish is its signature tacos.

These tacos are made with fresh, local ingredients and are bursting with flavor.

The tortillas are made in-house and fillings range from traditional carnitas to more adventurous options like pork belly or chorizo.

Each taco is topped with fresh salsa and other toppings, making it a delicious and filling snack.

Recommended hotels nearby: Brundage-Bungalows

6. Salmon River Brewery

411 railway avenue
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-4772

The Salmon River Brewery is a family-friendly brewpub and restaurant that serves classic pub food and beers in a rustic space.

Why this restaurant is a must

There's nothing like some good ol' pub grub for the best lunch in McCall.

Salmon River Brewery is the perfect spot for a casual meal and a few cold beers with friends.

The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, and the food is always fresh and delicious.

Whether you're looking for a light snack or a full meal, Salmon River Brewery has something for everyone.

what to eat

The most popular dish at Salmon River Brewery is their signature Plank Salmon.

A generous helping of fresh Atlantic salmon is grilled over an alder board, adding a subtle smoky flavor.

The salmon is served with homemade garlic puree, grilled asparagus and a creamy dill sauce.

The brewery also serves a range of other delicious dishes such as burgers, salads and sandwiches.

Recommended hotels nearby: Third Street Inn

7. FoggLifter-Café

1003 N 3. St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-5507

The FoggLifter Cafe is a relaxed, family-owned restaurant serving American breakfast and lunch.

Why this restaurant is a must

The FoggLifter Cafe is the perfect place to enjoy a meal with friends and family.

Or to take a break from your day and relax in its warm and welcoming atmosphere.

The café offers a range of freshly prepared dishes, from appetizers and soups to salads and sandwiches.

With its delicious dishes, friendly staff and cozy atmosphere, it's one of the coolest local restaurants around you.

what to eat

Get their signature FoggLifter sandwich.

This delicious sandwich is made with freshly baked sourdough bread topped with melted cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, and homemade honey-mustard sauce.

The flavors of the sweet and savory ingredients harmonize perfectly with each other, making it a must have for any sandwich lover.

Recommended hotels nearby: Best Western Plus McCall Lodge and Suites

See also:
Restaurants: Idaho Falls, ID
Restaurants: Coeur d'Alene

8. McCall Brewing Company

807 N 3. St. A
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-3309

McCall Brewing Company, a microbrewery and restaurant, has been producing quality ales since 1994.

Why this restaurant is a must

McCall Brewing Company is one of the best restaurants McCall has to offer for a night out with friends.

The atmosphere is warm and inviting with a cozy, rustic feel.

If you don't like the indoors, the outdoor terrace is the perfect spot for people-watching and soaking up some sun.

what to eat

The menu offers a wide range of craft beers and ales brewed on site, as well as local wines and spirits.

The most popular dish is the classic mac and cheese.

It's made with a creamy homemade cheese sauce, topped with breadcrumbs and served in a cast-iron skillet.

The burgers, sandwiches and salads are also popular and are great for lunch or dinner.

For a sweet treat, try the homemade ice cream, which comes in a variety of flavors.

Recommended hotels nearby: Brundage-Bungalows

9. Bistro 45

1101 N 3. St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-4515

Bistro 45 is a neighborhood restaurant and wine bar that serves light gourmet bites in a relaxed atmosphere.

Why this restaurant is a must

This next spot is one of the best places to eat in McCall if you don't want the drama.

Whatever the occasion, Bistro 45 is the perfect place for a casual dinner or a special occasion.

The vibe is warm and inviting, with soft lighting and rustic wood accents.

It's the perfect place to enjoy the best food in McCall.

The ambiance, delicious food and friendly staff make it a great place to enjoy a meal with friends or family.

what to eat

Get the Grilled Chicken and Brie Sandwich.

This delicious sandwich features succulent grilled chicken topped with creamy brie cheese and fresh cranberry relish.

The flavors combine to create the perfect balance of sweetness, acidity and savory goodness.

Recommended hotels nearby: Third Street Inn

10. Ruperts Restaurant

1101 N 3. St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-8108

Rupert's Restaurant is a family run restaurant serving American gourmet dishes and wines since 2005.

Why this restaurant is a must

If you're trying to decide on a date in McCall, this is one of the best downtown restaurants.

This cozy eatery offers its guests a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

It is furnished in a rustic style, with wood paneled walls and a fireplace creating a cozy and welcoming ambience.

The menu offers a variety of delicious dishes that appeal to a wide range of tastes.

With its delicious dishes and welcoming atmosphere, Rupert's Restaurant is perfect for a romantic dinner or a cozy evening with friends.

what to eat

The most popular dish is Rupert's Famous Prime Rib, a succulent cut of beef slowly roasted to perfection and served with a rich mushroom demi-glace.

Guests can enjoy other classic appetizers like salmon, steak, and chicken.

They also offer a decadent chocolate mousse that will satisfy any sweet tooth.

Recommended hotels nearby: Best Western Plus McCall Lodge and Suites

11. Mautstation Pizza & Pasta

410 Railroad Avenue
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-7818

Toll Station has been serving pizza and pasta to McCall locals and visitors for over 40 years.

Why this restaurant is a must

Toll Station Pizza & Pasta is more than just a stop - it's an experience.

The cozy atmosphere is perfect for an evening with friends and family or a romantic date.

The walls are adorned with old photos of the area, giving the restaurant a warm, welcoming atmosphere.

The menu is filled with various Italian dishes, from classic Italian pasta and pizza to specialty dishes.

No wonder it's one of the top rated restaurants in McCall when it comes to Italian food.

what to eat

We recommend the El Diablo Pizza — a flavorful, cheesy pie topped with pepperoni, jalapenos, and red onions.

Every bite is packed with flavor, making it a must-try for any visitor.

Recommended hotels nearby: Brundage-Bungalows

See also:
Restaurants in Twin Falls, ID

12. Burritos by KB

616 Nord 3rd Street
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-5500

KB's is a family run restaurant that serves authentic Mexican comfort food in a relaxed atmosphere.

Why this restaurant is a must

For a little slice of sun-kissed Mexico, KB's is one of the top McCall dishes to try.

The walls are adorned with vibrant colors and artwork, while the background music carries a touch of mariachi.

The sun streams through the windows creating a warm, inviting atmosphere.

It's the perfect backdrop to enjoying the best burritos in town.

what to eat

Get the Macho Burger if you're particularly hungry.

This giant burrito is filled with your choice of meat, rice, beans, cheese and salsa, then topped with creamy guacamole and sour cream.

Recommended hotels nearby: McCall condo

13. Frenchies

319 N 3. St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 630-6104

Frenchie's is a local restaurant serving burgers, PO boys and other soul foods in a charming setting.

Why this restaurant is a must

Frenchie's is a quaint restaurant that exudes the spirit of the Idaho mountains.

With an outdoor patio, cozy interior, and delicious menu, Frenchie's is the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or casual lunch.

It is easily one of McCall's best restaurants for a hearty meal.

what to eat

Frenchie's menu is filled with classic dishes made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

The most popular dish at Frenchie's is the classic French onion soup.

This hearty soup is made with caramelized onions, fresh herbs and a rich beef broth.

The soup is served with a toasted baguette topped with melted Gruyere cheese.

It's the perfect comfort food for a cold evening.

Recommended hotels nearby: Scandia Inn

14. Stax

600 N 3. St
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-8193

Stax is a family run restaurant offering a seasonal, home cooked menu.

Why this restaurant is a must

If you are looking for good restaurants in McCall that serve really good home cooking, Stax is a great option.

This cozy and welcoming restaurant will always transport you to a world of comfort and warmth.

With art, photography and soft music to complement your meal, what's not to love?

what to eat

The menu at Stax is full of delicious and unique dishes sure to please any palate. The most popular dish on the menu is the Stax Burger.

This delicious burger consists of a juicy grass-fed beef patty topped with melted cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and onions sandwiched between two toasted buns.

The burger is served with crispy fries, making it a filling and flavorful meal.

Recommended hotels nearby: Short break on Washington Street

15. Hometown pizza

337 Deinhard Ln
McCall, ID 83638
(208) 634-2596

Hometown Pizza has been a local staple for pizza, sandwiches, wings and salads since 1995.

Why this restaurant is a must

There's nothing like pampering your taste buds at one of McCall's finest restaurants.

Hometown Pizza is an experience like no other.

As you step through the doors, you are greeted by the warm and welcoming atmosphere.

The scent of fresh dough and hearty pizza sauce fills the air and gives you a feeling of comfort.

Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a night out with friends, Hometown Pizza is sure to be a hit.

what to eat

We recommend the Italiano.

It's a classic pizza with Italian sausage, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, black olives and red onions.

This pizza topped with mozzarella is perfect for cheese lovers.

The combination of the flavors of the Italian sausage and the sweetness of the red onions harmonizes perfectly for a pizza that leaves you wanting more.

Recommended hotels nearby: WorldMark McCall

Map of the best McCall restaurants

List of image sources

The 15 Best Restaurants in McCall, ID for 2023

• ice cream parlor
• My father's place
• Stacey Cake
• Steam boat
• cute city
• Salmon River Brewery
• Fogg Lifter Cafe
• McCall Brewing Company
• Bistro 45
• Ruperts Restaurant
• Mautstation Pizza & Pasta
• Burritos from KB
• Frenchies
• Stax
• home pizza